This report scores 13 camp-versus-camp narratives across 10 fault lines for the window of November 8 to 14, 2026, and none reaches the top watch tier: 11 stand in the active tier, W2, and two in W3. The lead card is the right’s fight over its own factions, carried this week onto Rep. Thomas Massie’s articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and the opening of the 2028 contest. James Lindsay wrote on 10 November of “an attempted coup of MAGA and the GOP led by a radical Woke Right calling itself the New Right”, and Mark Levin on 11 November of “a well-funded and highly organized network of Woke Reich groups”; that frame stands at 3.9, in W2. In the answering frame, at 3.5, Mike Cernovich wrote that “Neocons were wrong, and now are lying about basic things like polls”, and the two cards are locked, each running on the other’s statements. In Poland, Tommy Robinson, Jack Posobiec and the opposition leader Jaroslaw Kaczynski read the government’s account of the Krakow gunman as a lie aimed at its opponents, a frame that stands at 3.6. Twelve verdicts came back mixed and one reads core unsubstantiated by our checks. Six narratives read as ignited, two sit at near ignition, three sit at warming and two are cold.
Everything on this dashboard is ordinary political expression under this instrument, with one exception this window: items inside six narratives cleared our harm bar, were routed to the harm instrument and are reported only there, and what remains on those cards did not clear our harm gate. A narrative appearing here describes a framing pattern. Our separate harm methodology, with its own much higher bar, is reported in The Weather Report.
Our weekly harm report measures the narrow band of content that collectivizes, dehumanizes or incites against groups of people. This report measures selected framing contests within the material below the bar in the same week, under the same verification standard, with a second instrument.
This report tracks framing contests. An event happens, and within hours commentators on each side move from arguing about the event to arguing about what it reveals of the other camp’s motives and character. It states each narrative’s claim in a testable form, checks how the predictions it generates fare against what is observable, looks for the mirror narrative on the other side, and scores the whole contest for reach, intensity, penetration, elite adoption and mirror lock. It also watches each narrative for seven markers that it is drifting toward the territory the harm methodology covers.
The window has 26 trigger events: 11 in the United States, five in Britain, two in Canada and one each in Poland, France, Germany, Ireland, Spain and Sweden, nine national arenas in all, and two that span borders. Three items on the prior window’s watchlist show no new step inside this one. No card reaches the top watch tier, W1. The active tier, W2, has 11 cards, W3 has two and W4 has none. The woke-right frame, in its eleventh week, stands at 3.9. Rep. Thomas Massie held a press conference on 9 November on his eight articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth over the Iran war, and on 10 November the House voted 211 to 204 to refer them to the Judiciary Committee. On 9 November Laura Loomer wrote that “the Woke Reich is going to be a cancer in the 2028 cycle”, on 10 November James Lindsay wrote of “an attempted coup of MAGA and the GOP led by a radical Woke Right calling itself the New Right”, the faction around Tucker Carlson, and on 11 November Mark Levin wrote that “The enemy within includes a well-funded and highly organized network of Woke Reich groups”. The Krakow frame, carded for the first time, stands at 3.6. Six people were killed in the Krakow Main Market Square shooting of 7 November, Interior Minister Marcin Kierwinski said within hours that the gunman had been influenced by far-right ideology, and on 10 November Prime Minister Donald Tusk announced renewed work on laws on online content. Tommy Robinson posted on 9 November that the interior minister had “fully backtracked”, Jack Posobiec wrote on 10 November that “globalists want to censor the internet in Poland”, the Hungarian Conservative wrote that the label was aimed at damaging Tusk’s opposition, and Reuters reported that the Law and Justice leader Jaroslaw Kaczynski called it a “blatant lie”. The neocon frame, in its eighth week, stands at 3.5: on 8 November Mike Cernovich wrote that the founders of neoconservatism “were themselves Bolsheviks, and supporters of murdering Christians, same as Hamas”, and on 10 November he wrote “Neocons were wrong, and now are lying about basic things like polls”, Jack Posobiec wrote “Neocons are gay for war”, and Auron MacIntyre wrote of a “rabid attempt to disconnect cause and effect by the neocon media”. The Chappelle frame, carded this week on a lineage first carded in September, also stands at 3.5. Video of Dave Chappelle’s set at Madison Square Garden, in which he said he felt better since Charlie Kirk was killed and joked that Kirk was in hell, circulated from 7 November. On 8 November David Vance wrote of Chappelle and the podcaster Jennifer Welch “Believe them when they tell you they want us dead.”, and on 10 November Jack Posobiec wrote that the joke “was giving permission to kill conservatives”, the New York Post wrote that Chappelle had joined “the pack of lefty haters with a fetish for political violence”, and Fox News called the jokes part of a “pattern of leftists finding humor in violence”. The frame on Democrats who serve Israel stands at 3.4. On 10 November, 11 Democrats did not vote as the House referred Massie’s articles to committee, and on 13 November Senator Chris Van Hollen announced a challenge to Chuck Schumer for Senate Democratic leader. Cenk Uygur wrote on 11 November that “Israeli lobby wants pro-war Hegseth in place” and on 14 November, of Senator John Fetterman, that “Non-Americans hurt our side”, and Hasan Piker welcomed “center right” Democrats who “expose and purge themselves from the party”. The amnesty-deal frame, carded for the first time, stands at 3.3. On 60 Minutes on 8 November President Trump said his deportation policy was “too tough” on people with no criminal records and floated “some kind of legal status” for people here 10 and 15 years in a deal with Democrats. Geiger Capital wrote “Trump gave them a war in Iran and amnesty. Complete and total betrayal.”, Mike Cernovich wrote “Anyone pushing this is a worm tongue.”, and Auron MacIntyre wrote on 12 November of a “Full court press from GOP cucks for amnesty”. The open-borders frame stands at 3.2: on 12 November the Senate Republican Conference wrote that “Migrant caravans are marching to America because Democrats won the midterms. The entire world knows Democrats want open borders and mass amnesty.”, and Mike Cernovich wrote that “Democrats told Regan they would build a wall in exchange for amnesty. All they do is lie.” The frame on tech billionaires stands at 3.1. CNN projected on 10 November that California voters had rejected Proposition 40, a one-time 5% tax on residents with a net worth of over $1 billion, and Senator Bernie Sanders wrote “I’ve got bad news for these Oligarchs” and promised a federal billionaire wealth tax to “end your greed”; on 13 November he backed Van Hollen as the candidate to “take on the oligarchs”. The free-movement frame stands at 3.0. The government approved an asylum center for men beside the village of Piddington despite the village’s vote against it, and on 12 November Rupert Lowe MP wrote “A traitorous decision, just like every site housing illegals in working class communities and ANYWHERE else. Many people will go to prison.” On 10 November Eva Vlaardingerbroek, who said the Home Office had barred her from entering the UK, wrote that people who cross the Channel “are given free housing and citizenship”. The El-Sayed association frame stands at 2.9 and is listed in W2, the minimum watch tier for an ignited card. Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed told NPR on 12 November that he will take his Senate oath on a Quran. On 9 November Laura Loomer called him a “Muslim Brotherhood mouthpiece”, the Republican Jewish Coalition posted on 10 November that he “made excuses for an attempted mass casualty terror attack” on Temple Israel and on 11 November listed the national Democrats who backed him and ended “This is today's Democratic Party.”, and on 13 November Chaskel Bennett wrote that Chuck Schumer “became a proponent of antisemites like Graham Platner and Abdul El-Sayed”. The frame on Jensen Huang’s resignation, carded for the first time, stands at 2.8 and is listed in W2 under the same minimum. Nvidia announced on 12 November that Huang had resigned, four days after he acknowledged in a memo to staff an affair with a woman whom US officials suspect of spying for China. Geiger Capital posted on 11 November that “CIA/NSA is replacing him”, Robby Starbuck wrote on 12 November of “a very well funded op”, Cenk Uygur wrote on 13 November that “Someone wanted to assassinate Jensen Huang's character”, and Ben Norton wrote on 14 November that “US intelligence agencies carried out another coup”. The frame on Democrats and one-party rule stands at 2.7, in W3: Laura Loomer posted on 8 November that Democrats want “a super majority for eternity”, Auron MacIntyre wrote on 11 November of the filibuster that “the radical dems are going to shred it anyway”, and David Vance posted on 13 November that Democrats “want to abolish the Electoral College and end the Filibuster”, as the campaign to elect the president by national popular vote gained ground after the 3 November election. The Ole Miss frame, carded for the first time, stands at 2.5, in W3: after a doorbell video of two white students making monkey noises outside the apartment of three Black students drew national coverage, Matt Walsh wrote on 10 November “Woke is fully back, folks.” and on 11 November “These are not serious people.” Two cards carry a boundary mark, and on each of them the one-step move the mark gives would carry the score across a tier edge: elite adoption at 4 on the woke-right frame would carry its score above 4.0, into W1, and lock at 1 on the frame on tech billionaires would carry its score below 3.0, into W3. The El-Sayed association frame sits within 0.15 of the 3.0 edge and the free-movement frame on it, and neither carries a mark: one is ignited and the other at near ignition, W2 is the minimum tier for both, and no one-step move changes where either is listed.
Eleven cards play out in the United States arena, one in Britain and one in Poland, and none spans borders. Three each fall in culture and entertainment and in immigration, two each in education and culture, the general sweep and technology, one in foreign policy, and none in public health. On four cards an official, a candidate or a major outlet voices the claim’s central clauses as its own, the top elite-adoption anchor: the New York Post and Fox News in their own headlines on Chappelle; the Senate Republican Conference on open borders; Senator Sanders on tech billionaires; and Rupert Lowe MP on the asylum decision. The count covers the 13 scored cards.
The predictions are our own operationalizations of each frame, and reasonable readers may formulate different checks. Twelve verdicts came back mixed, one reads core unsubstantiated by our checks, and no card reads contradicted by our checks in this window. Contradicted means a probative check reached the claim’s core proposition, the central thing the frame asserts, and failed against what is observable, and no probative check on the core or the narrow reading came back true or mixed. Core unsubstantiated means no probative check reaches that core proposition in either direction, a weaker result than disproved. A card reads mixed where at least one probative check on its narrow reading came back true or mixed on independent evidence, and three things add no such support: a narrow reading left untested or unresolved, material produced by the frame’s own carrier unless its underlying evidence was separately verified, and political adoption of the claim such as a resolution, a vote or an endorsement, which shows a claim entering the mainstream. A mixed verdict on a compound claim substantiates none of its clauses on its own. On the woke-right frame, the narrow reading has an independent record: the House voted on Massie’s articles, and CNN describes the right’s loudest voices turning on one another. That the faction is staging a coup, is a foreign-promoted network and exists to destroy the conservative movement has only context behind it and is unsubstantiated on what we found. On the Krakow frame, the narrow reading has independent support: the interior minister named far-right ideology within hours, before prosecutors would say anything about motive, and Tusk tied renewed work on online-content laws to the attack. The clause that the minister admitted making the label up fails its check, since he told public radio he was not taking back anything he had said, and the core claim, that the label was aimed at the opposition and the online-content push is a pretext to silence critics, is unsubstantiated by our checks: the record describes the bill, fast-tracked in October before the attack, as making damaging content easier and quicker to remove, and holds nothing on what it would allow against the government’s critics. On the Huang frame, the verdict is core unsubstantiated by our checks. The pieces the carriers point to are documented: Huang had fought a long battle with officials and national security hawks over chip sales to China, the hawks welcomed his fall, material from a classified memo reached the press, and officials on the record said they had reached no conclusion that the woman was a spy. None of that reaches the claim itself: the outlets do not name their sources, and nothing in the record shows the agencies or the administration pressing Nvidia’s board before Huang resigned. On the frame on one-party rule, the narrow reading has independent support in a Democratic governor-elect’s backing of the national popular vote compact and calls to end the filibuster; whether the party intends to rule forever is a forecast no observation in the record settles. On the frame on Democrats who serve Israel, the narrow claim has independent support in the absent members’ ties to a group that the lobby’s campaign spending funded, and its strongest reading is unsubstantiated on what we found: no report shows the lobby taking a position on the impeachment or any member staying away on a cue, and the House Democratic leader publicly backed impeachment. On the amnesty-deal frame, the narrow reading has independent support: Colorado Politics reported that Trump floated legal status for people here 10 and 15 years, against the deportation pledge of the 2024 Republican platform. Trump ruled out amnesty the next day, which rests on his own account, and no poll of his voters was reached, so the claim of betrayal is unsubstantiated in the record. On the frame on tech billionaires, the spending against the tax is documented in campaign finance disclosures, and the claims that the donors are greedy and buy elections are unsubstantiated: the tax lost, and the result leaves open whether the spending decided the vote and what moved the donors. Confidence stands at moderate on nine cards and low on four: the woke-right card, the neocon card, the Chappelle card and the Ole Miss card.
Ten cards record a mirror that answered, two record a lock, and one records an unanswered mirror; an answered mirror is any opposing narrative on the same event carried in the window in the same national arena, commentary that leaves the card’s claim unaddressed included. A lock means each side runs on the other’s statements as its primary evidence. The two locked cards are the right’s fight over its own factions: on 10 November Auron MacIntyre wrote of “the neocon media” and Mike Cernovich that “Neocons were wrong”, on 13 November Mark Levin answered that “those who incessantly use the term neocon are actually using it as an attack on Jews”, and on 14 November Jack Posobiec wrote “I can't think of anything more Woke than people supposedly on the right trying to say you are racist for using the word 'neocon' for actual neocons”. The Ole Miss card records the unanswered mirror: NBC News, CNN and CBS News reported the video and the response to it, which is the coverage the card’s carriers frame, and no voice in the record answers the carriers’ claim about that coverage or frames Walsh or the right by motive or character. Coordination is a separate verdict on every card. All 13 cards read no coordination identified: each card’s below-bar record contains no linkage between its carriers beyond shared timing, no bridge account, no phrasing copied from one account to another, no named hub and no identified funder. This instrument records convergence on one story within hours as shared timing.
No card’s score moves on a trajectory multiplier this week. On the derived volume reading, each platform’s matches in the earlier window are carried forward at that platform’s own share of its collection, and the matches found are compared with that expectation. A card’s change is read against the week’s median change across the cards with five or more matching posts in both windows, and a multiplier is applied only where five or more cards set that median. Both windows run seven days, and each reading compares shares of each record’s collection. Three cards clear the five-post minimum this week, the woke-right frame, the neocon frame and the frame on tech billionaires, and their median change is a fall of about 44 percent (derived). The woke-right frame matched 38 posts, 37 of them on X, where its 38 in the earlier window, held at each platform’s share of that window’s collection, would give about 38 (derived); its share held level while the median fell, so it reads accelerating against that median, a reading that would carry 1.3. The neocon frame matched 14 posts where its 27 in the earlier window would give about 27 (derived), and the tech frame matched 5 where its 9 would give about 9 (derived); both read stable at 1.0. All three readings carry high confidence on nine comparable observation windows, and all three are published beside the scores as unapplied diagnostics, since three cards set the median, below the five a multiplier needs, so each card stays at 1.0. The other 10 cards have no reading: five matched nothing in the earlier window, and five had fewer than five matching posts in one of the two.
The research lanes apply our harm methodology’s gates to every item they consider for a card, and in this window items inside six carded narratives cleared them and set those cards’ status. A cleared item sets a card’s status only where its hostile content carries the card’s own claim or falls on the card’s own target, and where the item refers to the card’s trigger or its target in its own words, so an item that mentions a card’s target in one clause while its hostile content falls on someone else stays on the harm side and the card reads on its markers. An item that carries a card’s claim with a protected group put in the place of the actor the card accuses carries the card’s own claim: that substitution is how a frame between camps crosses our harm bar. The woke-right frame is ignited on a Laura Loomer post of 8 November, which cleared our harm bar at the hateful rung on the harm instrument’s separate branch for framing of a political camp, for moving the whole faction she calls the Woke Reich into a criminal class of traitors who will stage a military coup: it refers to the card’s target in its own words, and its hostile content falls on that target. The neocon frame is ignited on an anonymous board thread of 10 November, which cleared at the stigmatizing rung for framing Jewish people as a hidden controlling force behind the wing’s ideology: it refers to the neocons, the card’s target, in its own words, and makes the card’s claim of a dishonest wing hostile to America with Jewish people put in the place of the wing. The Chappelle frame is ignited on an Auron MacIntyre post of 8 November, which cleared at the hateful rung on the separate branch for casting the left as a pack of animals that wanted conservatives dead: it refers to the card’s trigger in its own words, and its hostile content falls on the left, the card’s target. The open-borders frame is ignited on a MacIntyre post of 13 November, which cleared at the stigmatizing rung for stating as fact that Democrats use the immigration of non-white people to shrink the white population: it refers to Democrats, the card’s target, in its own words, and carries the card’s claim about what Democrats want from immigration onto non-white immigrants as the instrument. The El-Sayed association frame is ignited on a Loomer post of 12 November, which cleared at the hateful rung for casting Muslim people as inbred and of low intelligence through El-Sayed, as their proxy: it refers to the card’s target in its own words, and its hostile content falls on him as the instance of the group. The Huang frame is ignited on a BasedSamParker post of 9 November, which cleared at the stigmatizing rung for casting Jewish people as a group set on controlling AI and destroying Huang: it refers to the card’s trigger in its own words, and makes the card’s claim, that a camp set out to bring Huang down by stoking fear of his China ties, with Jewish people put in the place of the intelligence agencies and China hawks. The routing rule is one rule: an item that clears the harm bar is scored and reported only on the harm side, it sets a narrative’s ignition status only under the two tests above and is recorded on that card as its handoff reference, and it never counts here as a below-bar example or as evidence for the charge priority score. The card keeps the framing contest and the below-bar remainder, and the harm instrument keeps the harm. The woke-right, neocon, Chappelle and open-borders cards stand in W2 on their computed scores, and the El-Sayed association card and the Huang card stand in W2 under the minimum watch tier for an ignited card.
Two narratives sit at near ignition, with no handoff. The Krakow frame has that status on one marker in a commentator-tier carrier: a vermin metaphor that Tommy Robinson set on the prime minister on 11 November, a public official, and the one post in the card’s arena that cleared our harm bar, a board thread of 8 November, falls on the far-right camp, outside the card’s claim and target, and is reported in The Weather Report. The free-movement frame has that status on one marker at official tier: the end state moves from opposing a planning decision to imprisoning the officials behind it, in Lowe’s “Many people will go to prison.” Three narratives sit at warming: the frame on Democrats who serve Israel, on two instances of a charge hardened into a standing trait of the faction, Uygur’s “Non-Americans hurt our side” and a Piker post that sets a character trait on the party’s centrists; the amnesty-deal frame, on Cernovich’s “Anyone pushing this is a worm tongue.”; and the Ole Miss frame, on Walsh’s “These are not serious people.” Two narratives are cold: no marker is observed on the frame on tech billionaires or on the frame on one-party rule. Several cleared harm items mention a card’s target and stay on the harm side, since their hostile content falls outside the card’s claim or refers to neither its trigger nor its target: posts by Nigel Farage and Lowe on the asylum decision cleared on migrants; Lowe’s post of 9 November on Trump’s offer and Walsh’s post of the same day calling for more deportations cleared on undocumented immigrants; Walsh’s post of 10 November and two board posts on the Ole Miss video cleared on Black people; in the arena of the open-borders card, a MacIntyre post of 8 November and a Loomer post of 13 November cleared on Muslim people and on foreign-born Americans; and Loomer’s posts on El-Sayed and Muslim candidates in the days of the one-party card cleared on Muslim people.
The right’s fight over its own factions is the arena where each side carries a card and each card is ignited, and the harm instrument has the items that cleared its bar, which are scored and reported in The Weather Report: Loomer’s post of 8 November on the woke-right side and the board thread of 10 November on the neocon side, set out above. On this instrument the fight is two locked cards, the woke-right frame at 3.9 and the neocon frame at 3.5, both in W2, and each faction’s account of the week is the other’s evidence.
Items that cleared our harm bar outside these handoffs appear in The Weather Report, which publishes its own counts for this window, and none of them is carded here. Where a card’s carrier also appears in the harm corpus, the card says so. A cleared harm item is never a card’s carrier or below-bar example and never counts toward its charge priority score. One item is never reported both as a harm hit and as a polarization example.
Near ignition and ignited are review statuses. They escalate our checking cadence and record where an item was handed off to the other instrument, and they carry no verdict about anyone.
Twelve of the 13 narratives drew a response in the record, and the Ole Miss card drew none. The note on each of the twelve records the form the answer took, from a motive narrative of the opposing camp’s own to reporting or merits argument with no counter-imputation in it, and both ends appear this window. On the right’s fight over its own factions, each faction’s account of the week is the other’s evidence, and the two cards are locked. On the Chappelle frame, Hasan Piker read the right’s response as a cancellation campaign it once opposed, writing on 8 November “RW TRIES KIRK CANCELLATION AGAIN W/ CHAPELLE AND JENNIFER WELCH”, and Matt Walsh cross-cited the answer on 11 November. On the frame on Democrats who serve Israel, Mark Levin wrote on 14 November that “Van Hollen is the Muslim Brotherhood and CAIR candidate for majority leader”, and Chaskel Bennett wrote on 13 November that Schumer “became a proponent of antisemites like Graham Platner and Abdul El-Sayed”; Uygur answers Fetterman by name and Levin answers Van Hollen by name, and neither side’s case runs on the other’s posts. On Krakow, EUobserver ran “The Kraków shooting: A Polish tragedy, a Russian opportunity” on 11 November, and the other camp reads the dispute over the label as a disinformation campaign by the far right; neither camp cites the other’s named voices. On the amnesty deal, the framed leaders answered in their own terms: Trump said on 9 November “There won't be amnesty”, and Senate Majority Leader John Thune said Republicans would “emphatically oppose” Democratic efforts to reopen the border; MacIntyre called the answer “in no way clarifying”. On open borders, House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries said Democrats will not give “a dime” to the “violent mass deportation machine”, Rep. Ro Khanna pledged to cut wall money, and Senator Van Hollen proposed funding health subsidies by cutting ICE’s budget; none of them cites the conference, Thune or the commentators. On tech billionaires, Boring Business wrote that “a wealth tax makes absolutely no sense”, and the New York Post reported the result as a setback for progressives; neither cites Sanders, and Sanders cites neither. On the asylum decision, the government spoke in its own terms, the Housing Secretary on the need for accommodation and a minister on the account that asylum seekers there are not detained, and voices on Bluesky outside government, a political scientist among them, answered Restore Britain by label; no government voice in the record cites Lowe or Vlaardingerbroek. On El-Sayed, OccupyDemocrats called JD Vance a “bigot” who “will be forced to swear him in on a Qur'an”, and the Financial Times called Trump’s “jihadist” charge an outlier’s, below card level; no reply cites the coalition’s or Loomer’s posts. On Huang, Senator Tom Cotton wrote on 12 November that “Communist China continues to lie, steal, and deceive to acquire advanced American AI chips”, Loomer that officials “turned a blind eye to Jensen Huang being compromised by the CCP”, and Posobiec that “The CCP just took down the CEO”; none of the opposing voices cites Norton, Uygur, Starbuck or Geiger Capital, and none of those carriers cites them. On one-party rule, Mother Jones and OccupyDemocrats ran the Democratic camp’s own frame on the Republicans after the result, and no post in the record answers the carriers’ claim directly.
The camp label is derived from each card’s carrier set and is coarse, and the carrier-set paragraph on each card is the authoritative account of who carried a narrative.
Each card is classed from its origin camp as right-origin, left-origin, or cross-party or other, and the table above lists every classed card with the basis for its classing, so a reader can class any card differently and recount.
| Origin side | Cards | Mixed evidence | Contradicted by our checks | Core unsubstantiated by our checks | Low confidence | Ignited | Near ignition |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Right-origin | 10 | 10 | 0 | 0 | 4 | 5 | 2 |
| Left-origin | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Cross-party or other | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 |
| Total | 13 | 12 | 0 | 1 | 4 | 6 | 2 |
Ten of the 13 cards are right-origin, two are left-origin and one is cross-party or other, and every card has a class this week. The right-origin cards are the Krakow frame, carried by commentators of the national-populist right, a conservative outlet and the leader of Poland’s right-wing opposition; the Chappelle frame, carried by conservative outlets and commentators; the amnesty-deal frame, carried by nationalist commentators inside the Republican coalition against their own coalition’s leaders; the open-borders frame, carried by Republican official channels and a commentator of the right; the free-movement frame, carried by a British nationalist party leader in Parliament and a nationalist commentator; the El-Sayed association frame, carried by the Republican Jewish Coalition, the conservative Media Research Center and commentators of the right; the frame on one-party rule, carried by commentators of the pro-Trump right; the Ole Miss frame, carried by a conservative commentator and anonymous board posters; and two cards on which one faction of the right frames another, so that origin and target sit on the same side: the woke-right frame and the neocon frame. The left-origin cards are the frame on tech billionaires, carried by a senator who caucuses with the Democrats and two left-leaning national magazines, and the frame on Democrats who serve Israel, carried by commentators of the Democratic Party’s left and aimed at the party’s own pro-Israel leaders and centrists, so that origin and target sit on the same side. The cross-party card is the Huang frame, carried by voices from the antiwar left, the progressive left, the right and the technology investor class against the US national security establishment. All four low-confidence verdicts fall on right-origin cards, the woke-right, neocon, Chappelle and Ole Miss cards. Five of the six ignited cards are right-origin, and the sixth is the cross-party Huang card; both cards at near ignition, the Krakow frame and the free-movement frame, are right-origin. Both left-origin cards read mixed; one reads warming and one is cold.
Eight narratives carded last week were carded again this week, five were carded with no card of last week joined to them, and five narratives carded last week were not carded this week. Both windows run seven days, and the volume readings compare shares of each record’s collection. Two continuing narratives moved tier, both down. The El-Sayed association frame moved down from W1 to W2 and was scored at 2.9, carried this week past the result onto the senator-elect’s first acts and his party’s leadership fight; it is listed in W2 under the minimum watch tier for an ignited card, on Loomer’s post of 12 November. The frame on Democrats and one-party rule moved down from W2 to W3 and was scored at 2.7; its card is cold this week, where last week’s card was ignited. Two continuing narratives crossed into the harm instrument: the woke-right frame, on Loomer’s post of 8 November, and the open-borders frame, on MacIntyre’s post of 13 November, both set out in the ignition section above, and neither card was ignited last week. The neocon frame and the El-Sayed association frame were ignited last week and are ignited again on handoffs from this window. The woke-right frame stays in W2 at 3.9 and leads the board. Of the five with no card of last week joined to them, which the ledger below counts as newly carded, four are new this week: the Krakow frame, in W2 at 3.6; the amnesty-deal frame, in W2 at 3.3; the Huang frame, in W2 at 2.8; and the Ole Miss frame, in W3 at 2.5. The fifth, the Chappelle frame, in W2 at 3.5, returns to a lineage first carded in September on the claim that the left celebrated the killing of Charlie Kirk. The five narratives carded last week and not carded this week are the faith frame on El-Sayed, the slavery-apology frame, the frame on the party’s war wing, the frame on Poland’s tribunal dispute and the frame on Stephen Miller’s appointment.
Crossed into the harm instrument marks a continuing narrative whose card is ignited this week after its card last week was not. Every ignited card has a handoff, an item that cleared the harm bar, and the crossing mark goes only to those not ignited last week. Six cards are ignited this week: two crossed, each on a lineage ignited in weeks before last; two were ignited last week as well, with handoffs this window that continue that status; and two had no card last week, so there is nothing to cross from.
5 narratives carded last week are not carded this week.
| Narrative | Continues | Tier | Harm instrument |
|---|---|---|---|
| Laura Loomer, Mark Levin and James Lindsay cast the New Right faction around Tucker Carlson as an enemy inside the conservative movement that is staging a coup of Trump and the Republican Party, in the frame's eleventh week | Laura Loomer, James Lindsay and Jordan Schachtel cast the New Right faction around Tucker Carlson as a network of podcasters that set out to make Republicans lose the 3 November midterms, in the frame's tenth week | no change | crossed this week |
| Mike Cernovich, Jack Posobiec and Auron MacIntyre cast the Republican Party's neocon wing as a dishonest war party that lies about the midterm defeat and is Bolshevik at root, in the frame's eighth week | Mike Cernovich and Auron MacIntyre cast the Republican Party's neocon wing as no ally of the base that hoped for the 3 November midterm defeat, in the frame's seventh week | no change | no crossing |
| The Republican Jewish Coalition, Laura Loomer, newsbusters and Chaskel Bennett cast Senator-elect El-Sayed as a Muslim Brotherhood mouthpiece who excused a terror attack, and the national Democrats who backed him as spineless and as the face of today's Democratic Party | Mike Rogers, the Republican Jewish Coalition, Tommy Robinson and Laura Loomer cast El-Sayed as loyal to a foreign cause and tied to the Muslim Brotherhood, and the national Democrats who backed him as putting party power above the safety of Michigan's Jewish community | W1 to W2 | no crossing |
| Cenk Uygur and Hasan Piker read the 11 Democratic absences on the Hegseth impeachment vote and the fight over Chuck Schumer's leadership as proof that the Democratic Party's pro-Israel leaders and centrists protect the Iran war for Israel against their own voters | The Intercept, The Nation and Max Blumenthal read Haley Stevens's endorsement of Mike Rogers as proof that centrist, pro-Israel Democrats put Israel ahead of their own nominee and would give up the Michigan seat to keep the party's critics of Israel from power | no change | no crossing |
| Laura Loomer, David Vance and Auron MacIntyre read the Democrats' push to replace the Electoral College and end the filibuster as a plan for a super majority for eternity | Laura Loomer and David Vance read the Democrats' win of the House and Senate as the start of permanent one-party rule, with a packed Supreme Court, new states and jail for those who refuse the party's agenda | W2 to W3 | no crossing |
| The Senate Republican Conference and a right-wing commentator cast the Democratic Party as a whole as wanting open borders and mass amnesty, drawing migrant caravans with its midterm win and lying about enforcement in any deal | The Senate Republican Conference casts the Democratic Party as a whole as set on defunding ICE and Border Patrol, ending deportations and putting immigrants in the country illegally ahead of citizens, and commentators carry the frame past the 3 November election into a Democratic Congress | no change | crossed this week |
| Rupert Lowe MP and Eva Vlaardingerbroek cast the Burnham government's approval of an asylum site at Piddington and the Home Office's decisions as traitorous acts for migrants against the British people, for which officials will go to prison | Rupert Lowe MP and Tommy Robinson cast the Burnham government's settlement concessions, the Johnson government's visa record and the Home Office's staff as betraying the British people in migrants' favor | no change | no crossing |
| Bernie Sanders reads the defeat of California's billionaire tax as the work of greedy oligarchs, led by tech founders, who buy elections | Bernie Sanders and 404 Media read the 3 November vote and the fight over California's billionaire tax as proof that tech billionaires are an oligarchy that puts its money above children's lives and buys government | no change | no crossing |
2 narratives crossed into the harm instrument this week: each card is ignited, and its card last week was not. Their rows are marked in the table.
Each line is one narrative compared with itself a week earlier, joined on a key assigned when the narrative was first carded. Text similarity between the two weeks plays no part in the join. The two instruments are reported separately and never combined into a single direction, because they measure different things on different scales.
The window runs from Sunday 8 November 2026 to Saturday 14 November 2026, 00:00 to 23:59 UTC, 7 days. The edition is published on Sunday 15 November. The record’s last collection closed at 00:08 UTC on Sunday 15 November, after the window ended.
The research lanes apply our harm methodology's gates to every item they card, and the harm hunts read the gated set of the record and samples of the rest. Items that clear the gates are reported in The Weather Report, under the routing rule stated in the ignition section above. Items that do not clear them run through a two-prong polarization gate: the commentary's primary object must be the motives or character of the camp being framed, which may be the carrier's own, with the event's merits set aside, and at least one of eight named polarizing operations must be present. Heat alone never codes, and documented, sourced motive claims never code. This instrument states whether an item cleared our harm bar and how a camp-versus-camp narrative scored. It makes no legal finding in any jurisdiction, and the countries on this board do not share one speech standard. The harm side’s six rungs, from biased framing through stigmatizing, hateful, threatening and glorifying violence to calling for violence, are each coded on a written definition.
Each narrative's base score is the five-factor geometric mean, CPS_base = (R·I·P·E·L)^(1/5): Reach, Intensity, Penetration, Elite adoption, and Lock, each anchored 1 to 5, combined by geometric mean so no single factor can dominate. The published charge priority score is that base times a trajectory multiplier where one is applied, capped at 5: CPS = min(5, CPS_base × τ). No card has an applied multiplier this week, and every published score equals its base score. The score is plotted on a 0 to 5 axis. Watch tiers: W1 at 4.0 and above, W2 at 3.0, W3 at 2.0, W4 below.
Scores are published to one decimal. A score within 0.15 of a tier edge is marked at the boundary, and the mark gives one factor, the value a one-step move would give it, and the score the card would then read. Two cards carry a boundary mark in this window: on the woke-right frame the step would carry the score above 4.0, into W1, and on the frame on tech billionaires below 3.0, into W3. A step counts only when it changes the tier a card is listed in, so a card at near ignition or ignited carries no mark at the 3.0 edge, where W2 is its minimum tier. A boundary mark records how thin a tier placement is.
Coordination is a separate verdict on every card. All 13 cards in this set read no coordination identified. That verdict says what each card’s below-bar record contains: no linkage between its carriers beyond shared timing, no bridge account, no phrasing copied from one account to another, no named hub and no identified funder. A finding of overt coordination needs willing co-participants, so a card carried by a single account reads no coordination identified, and a one-way relay from one surface to another reads as convergence. Independent origin is recorded only where positive evidence for it exists.
The ignition instrument runs beside the score. It never changes the five factors or the computed score. It can change where a card is listed: W2 is the minimum watch tier for a card at near ignition or ignited, and such a card is shown with its computed score beside it. In this window the rule lists two cards in W2 that compute into W3: the El-Sayed association card at 2.9 and the Huang card at 2.8, both ignited. The other ignited and near-ignition cards compute into W2. Seven markers, each keyed to a construct our harm methodology already defines, produce a status: cold, warming, near ignition, or ignited. Ignited means an item cleared the harm bar and is reported there.
The trajectory multiplier is a corpus-share reading. Volume is a card’s matches per thousand collected posts in a window, taken on each platform against that platform’s own collection: each platform’s matches in the earlier window are carried forward at its own share, and the matches found are compared with that expectation, so a share moves differently from the raw count behind it. The change is read against the week’s median change across the cards with five or more matching posts in both windows, so a movement the whole collection shares lifts no card on its own. The bands are set in advance and recorded as tunable: a change more than 15 percent above that median reads accelerating and carries 1.3, a change more than 15 percent below it reads decaying and carries 0.6, and anything between reads stable and carries 1.0. The multiplier a card has is shown on the card. A platform whose posts collected per day move by more than three fifths between the two windows is left out of the reading. A multiplier is applied where both windows clear the five-post minimum, five or more cards set the week’s median, the card is past its first appearance and the reading carries at least medium confidence, which counts the comparable observation windows behind it. Where that test is unmet the score stands on its five factors alone, and a reading that can still be computed is published beside the score as an unapplied diagnostic with its confidence marked. In this window three cards have a reading, each on nine comparable observation windows: the woke-right frame reads accelerating, a reading that would carry 1.3, and the neocon frame and the frame on tech billionaires read stable at 1.0. The week’s median change, a fall of about 44 percent (derived), comes from those three cards alone, the only cards with five or more matching posts in both windows, so all three readings are published as unapplied diagnostics and all three cards stay at 1.0. The other 10 have 1.0 with no reading: five matched nothing in the earlier window and five have fewer than five matching posts in one of the two.
The logic test states each frame's claim as a prediction-generating hypothesis and checks the predictions against what is observable, with sources. The predictions are our own operationalizations of the frame, and reasonable readers may formulate different checks; where a frame supports both a narrow and a strong reading, both are tested and each check states which one it touches. Every prediction is shown with its own result in the drill. The verdict scale has five values: supported by our checks, mixed evidence, contradicted by our checks, core unsubstantiated by our checks, and not testable from available evidence. A card reads supported where the imputed motive survives the checks. It reads mixed where at least one probative check on its narrow reading came back true or mixed on independent evidence; three things add no such support, a narrow reading left untested or unresolved, material produced by the frame's own carrier unless its underlying evidence was separately verified, and political adoption of the claim such as a resolution, a vote or an endorsement. Where no narrow reading holds, the next two verdicts turn on the claim's core proposition, the central thing the frame asserts, which on these cards is usually a motive or a standing trait imputed to a camp. A card reads contradicted by our checks where a probative check reached that core proposition and failed against what is observable, and no probative check on the core or the narrow reading came back true or mixed. A card reads core unsubstantiated by our checks where no probative check reaches that core proposition in either direction, so our record neither supports the claim nor tells against it and the card states what each check looked for. A check marked context only records a fact that cannot tell the claim's readings apart; it has no weight in the verdict, and the drill shows it as ‘context only, carries no weight’. A check whose observation would hold in ordinary politics whatever the truth of the claim, such as a party funding its own nominee or a party's senators objecting to a proposal on fiscal grounds, is marked the same way. A check on a narrow reading is judged against that reading as the card states it, and the same fact has the same weight on both cards of a pair. A mixed verdict on a compound claim substantiates none of its clauses on its own. Verdicts report how each frame's predictions fared against what is observable, as this instrument operationalizes them; they leave the underlying policy question open, and a camp's broader concern can remain entirely legitimate while its narrative's checks come back contradicted.
A card quotes its live source verbatim, or the outlet that carried the quote, and items without such a source are excluded before scoring. The collection behind this window has 14,452 posts dated inside it, 5,777 on X, 6,456 on Bluesky and 2,219 on 4chan, where a 4chan row is a thread’s opening post, alongside 2,571 news rows. The research lanes worked from shortlists of the window’s X and Bluesky posts above an engagement threshold, with the news rows that matched each lane, and searched the window’s posts on X, Bluesky and the boards for each card’s carriers and its mirror. Candidates drop out for several reasons, and the polarization gate is only one of them: no codable text, no readable source, an object the identification bar puts out of reach, or a primary object that is the event’s merits with no camp’s motives in view. The lanes apply the harm methodology’s gates to every item before it can be carded here; candidates that clear them are routed to that instrument and carded nowhere here, and the ignition section above records where that happened in this window. Clustering requires a shared canonical claim on the same fault line: a card has one canonical claim, its items may come from several trigger events in the window when each of them makes that claim, and the card lists its events. A card requires either two independent carriers or a single carrier at official or major-outlet tier. Research lanes are collection beats; fault lines are the terrain the narratives land on. Every lane runs the same queries for both camps, and a card records a mirror as unanswered only after a search for one. Private individuals are described by role and never named, whether or not the press identifies them. Two kinds of person are public actors for this purpose and are named: a person charged or convicted in a widely reported court case, and an activist who acts in public under their own name or a chosen one. Jerm has final editorial responsibility.
The roster is the monitored frame, and the collection combines the handles on our lists, the two boards, a Bluesky network search and a news table. The figures cover the roster, the handle lists and the posts collected for 8 to 14 November 2026.
| Source | Handles on our lists | Handles collected | Handles that returned a post | Posts collected |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bluesky | 52 (4 matched to a roster category) | 888 | 873 | 6,456 |
| X | 152 (46 matched to a roster category) | 111 | 107 | 5,777 |
| News outlets | not applicable | 1,308 | 1,257 | 2,571 |
| 4chan boards | not applicable | 2 | 2 | 2,219 |
The roster has 1,034 accounts across 23 categories, and 136 of them sit in more than one category, so the category column below counts more accounts than the roster has. Handles collected counts the handles that stored a post by the collection that closed the record on 15 November, in both tables, and handles that returned a post and posts collected count the posts and headlines dated in the window that the same collection stored. A handle the collector read that returned nothing leaves no row. The Bluesky collector also runs a network search beyond the listed handles, so its collected count exceeds its list; the X collector reads only the handles listed.
| Roster category | Accounts |
|---|---|
| Anti-Establishment, Socialist and Anti-War Media | 74 |
| Great Replacement and White Nationalist Accounts | 73 |
| Far-Right, Nationalist and Culture War Figures | 65 |
| Pro-Israel and Zionist Accounts | 65 |
| Alternative Media, Sovereign and Conspiracy Theorists | 63 |
| Far-Left, Anti-Imperialist and Communist Commentators | 62 |
| Pro-Immigration, Sanctuary and Migrant Rights Accounts | 58 |
| Anti-Semitic and Syncretic Conspiracy Accounts | 56 |
| Black Radical, Pan-Africanist and Marxist-Leninist Factions | 56 |
| Islamophobic, Anti-Islam and Counter-Jihad Accounts | 56 |
| Anti-Establishment Tech, Finance and Geopolitical Dissidents | 55 |
| Anti-Illegal Immigration and Border Nationalist Accounts | 55 |
| Anti-China and Dissident Accounts | 50 |
| Pro-China and State-Affiliated Media Accounts | 49 |
| Extreme Christian Nationalist and Dominionist Accounts | 47 |
| Anti-Vaccine and Medical-Freedom Extremist Accounts | 46 |
| Anarchist, Eco-Radical and Left-Libertarian Organizers | 45 |
| Radical Islamist and Salafi-Jihadist Ideologue Accounts | 44 |
| Pro-Feminist and Intersectionality Accounts | 43 |
| The Manosphere and Red Pill Ecosystem | 41 |
| Anti-Feminist, Traditionalist and Counter-Feminist Accounts | 39 |
| Anti-Christian, Militant Atheist and Secularist Accounts | 38 |
| Anti-Technology and Anti-AI Extremist Accounts | 26 |
The table below sorts the 46 of 152 X handles that match a roster category by name, and a handle on more than one category is counted in each. The other 106 are handles our records list without a category, and they are collected and read the same way. Thirteen categories returned an X post this week.
| Roster category | X handles matched | Collected | Returned a post | Posts |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Islamophobic, Anti-Islam and Counter-Jihad Accounts | 8 | 8 | 8 | 643 |
| Anti-Illegal Immigration and Border Nationalist Accounts | 12 | 12 | 12 | 509 |
| Far-Right, Nationalist and Culture War Figures | 12 | 11 | 10 | 461 |
| Alternative Media, Sovereign and Conspiracy Theorists | 2 | 2 | 2 | 194 |
| Great Replacement and White Nationalist Accounts | 7 | 6 | 5 | 167 |
| Anti-Establishment, Socialist and Anti-War Media | 5 | 4 | 4 | 78 |
| Far-Left, Anti-Imperialist and Communist Commentators | 5 | 3 | 3 | 73 |
| Pro-Israel and Zionist Accounts | 3 | 2 | 2 | 62 |
| Extreme Christian Nationalist and Dominionist Accounts | 2 | 2 | 2 | 60 |
| The Manosphere and Red Pill Ecosystem | 1 | 1 | 1 | 55 |
| Anti-Establishment Tech, Finance and Geopolitical Dissidents | 2 | 2 | 2 | 29 |
| Anti-Semitic and Syncretic Conspiracy Accounts | 2 | 2 | 2 | 25 |
| Pro-China and State-Affiliated Media Accounts | 4 | 2 | 2 | 19 |
| Pro-Immigration, Sanctuary and Migrant Rights Accounts | 5 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Anarchist, Eco-Radical and Left-Libertarian Organizers | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
The record’s last collection closed at 00:08 UTC on Sunday 15 November, after the window ended, and anything posted, reported or answered after the record closes is outside the record. Our X record joins the nightly pull list, which the collector rebuilds each night from a fixed core of handles and the roster handles named in the past seven days of our news table, with a read before the record closed of 38 harm-relevant roster handles it had not read recently. Of the 152 roster X handles, 107 carried posts dated inside the window and 45 carry no in-window post in our record, so a camp that leans on those 45 accounts may read thinner on X where their posts were missed, and a low count for a camp’s carriage, an unanswered mirror or a single-carrier reading may partly reflect what our roster and platforms reach. The X collector skipped its run of 07:31 UTC on 8 November at its weekly spending ceiling, and its run of 9 November stopped at its per-run spending ceiling before it had read every handle on its list, leaving the rest to the next run. X ran below its four-week median for the same weekday on six of the seven days in our record, and at about three quarters of it from 11 to 14 November, so the collector read fewer posts on those dates. Each handle is read from its last stored post, so later runs took up the posts the short runs left, within the page cap, and some posts from those dates may still be absent after those reads. The collector’s page cap of 200 posts on one read cut three accounts short, and their posts beyond the cap are missing from the record: brianstelter on 9 November, ChinaDaily on 10 November, and DavidVance on the read of 15 November, the account of a carrier on the Chappelle card and the frame on one-party rule. The lanes searched in English, so the Krakow frame and its answers are read through posts and outlets in English, and Polish-language discourse is outside what they searched. Most Bluesky posts in the record come from news outlets, so Bluesky carriage on these cards mostly measures outlet coverage. Each nightly news search asks for articles from the last two days, and the counts here take only headlines dated inside the window. Replies and reposts sit largely outside the collection, and on X they are left out at collection, so an answer made in a reply thread is mostly outside the record. Outside these platforms, surfaces the collection cannot systematically see, including several large closed platforms, are underrepresented, and a narrative living mainly on them would read here as smaller than it is.
The cleared items that set the ignition statuses on this page come from the harm hunts, which read a gated set of the record and random samples of the rest. The reading gate counts 17,021 posts and headlines, two fewer than the 14,452 posts and 2,571 headlines dated in the window, because two Bluesky posts are stored twice and the gate counts each post once. The hunts read 8,972 of the 17,021 posts and headlines collected: every post the ranking classifier scored 0.3 or above or could not score, every headline, every post by an account with 5 or more confirmed items in earlier weeks, anonymous board posts it scored 0.15 or above, and random samples of the rest. The hunts read a random 408 (25 percent) of the 1,607 posts that were anonymous board posts the classifier scored below 0.15 or came from accounts with 1 to 4 confirmed items in earlier weeks; the 408 held 1 hit, which puts the hits among the other 1,199 at about 3 (95 percent interval 0 to 21, derived). The hunts read a random 368 (5 percent) of the 7,218 posts from accounts with no confirmed item in earlier weeks; the 368 held no hit, which puts the hits among this week’s other 6,850 at 72 or fewer (the upper end of a 95 percent interval, derived) from this week’s sample alone, and at 21 or fewer (the upper end of a 95 percent interval, derived) pooled over 4 weeks (1,520 posts read, no hit), assuming the share of hits among these posts held steady over those weeks. A cleared item among the posts the hunts left unread could have set another card’s status. A carded post outside the harm hunts’ read set had the harm check from the lane alone, with no harm verifier.
Private individuals are never named, whether or not the press identifies them, and are described by role where a card needs them at all; the two kinds of public actor named in the method note are the exception. A reader cannot follow every thread on these cards back to a person as a result. Where a first-party post was not retrievable, quotes are cited to the outlet that carried them.
Penetration is scored from carrier-set breadth as a stated judgment; no within-camp sample was drawn, so every penetration score is an unvalidated qualitative estimate with no defined denominator behind it. The engagement and selection gates favor the loudest voices, so a penetration score is likely to lean upward, and each describes the lanes we read, never the camp as a whole. Reach is scored on qualitative anchors, and X’s view counts, where shown, are capture-time counters that do not count unique readers and are no lower bound on audience.
Three cards have a trajectory reading in this window, and no score moves on one; the other 10 scores say nothing about how a narrative’s volume moved between the two windows. The five-post minimum behind that is a chosen threshold below which a count is treated as noise, a standing rule under review that has not been validated, recorded as tunable with a date, and the five-card minimum for the week’s median is a chosen threshold of the same kind. The week’s median change rests on the three cards that clear the five-post minimum, the woke-right frame, the neocon frame and the frame on tech billionaires, so each reading sets one card against the other two, and all three readings are diagnostics. The woke-right frame’s reading rests on 38 matching posts in each window, 37 of them on X each time, and the neocon frame’s on 27 and 14, most of them on X, so the gaps in this window’s X record set out above bear on both directly. A share of one window’s corpus set against a share of another measures the collection as well as the discourse, in an unknown proportion.
The published product has a selection bias of its own, the one section 15 of our methodology sets out. Not-testable verdicts are expected to be common, W4 narratives are logged and go unwritten, and false positives are the first-class error the instrument optimizes against, so these reports over-represent charged narratives that happened to generate falsifiable predictions. That effect lives in the publication layer, apart from any collection or platform effect.
Camp attribution has no ground truth. Origin camp is coded from the carrier set’s observable alignment, and heterodox voices and single-issue coalitions resist clean attribution; the two cards of the fight inside the right and the card on Democrats who serve Israel, on which origin and target sit on the same side, and the cross-party Huang card are cases of it. The origin-side split above can be read only so far. Our monitored roster is weighted toward right-of-center accounts on X, and an engagement threshold sits under every lane, so the card set’s balance by side reflects what the lanes read before any check is run, and a side with more cards has more chances at every verdict and every status. The split covers the scored cards.
The harm side’s rungs, named on the ignited cards above, have been coded on the written definitions our methodology adopted on 3 October 2026, so a rung named here is comparable only with rungs coded on those definitions.
Escalation markers in this window are recorded as marker instances, each with its own source URL and date on the card that carries it. The status a set of markers produces is still a judgment under the marker rules, and clicking a marker opens the card so the judgment can be read against its evidence.
The charge priority score orders our own review queue. Its reach, penetration, and elite-adoption factors move together in practice, since a narrative carried by elites tends to score up on all three, so nearby scores should be read as a tier. Scores are displayed to one decimal, because five whole-number judgments combined by geometric mean support no finer reading than that; a gap of a tenth or two is inside the noise of those five factors, and cards inside a tier are listed by score for reference, with no ranking drawn from a gap that small. Rounding can place a card either side of a tier cut, so a score within 0.15 of a tier edge carries a boundary mark that gives one factor and the score a one-step move in it would give; a card held in W2 by the minimum watch tier carries none at the 3.0 edge, and two cards carry a mark in this window. The factor anchors, the marker list and the tier cutoffs in this instrument are conventions still under calibration, and every one of them is recorded as tunable with a date attached, so a later change to any of them stays visible against this window.
This research is unpaid volunteer work. If you want it to continue, the fundraiser is the way to help.
Support the fundraiserBlind verdict agreement: 25 of 28 as of 2026-07-24